Honda Mobilio vs Maruti Ertiga vs Toyota Innova
The Indian MPV market is all abuzznow with the new launches lined up. First among these, will be the HondaMobilio. The newest kid on the block will have a tough time with thecompetition being intense from the segment leader Innova and Maruti’s offeringin this space- Ertiga.
Maruti Ertiga Honda Mobilio Toyota Innova
So let’s take a look at how Honda will measure up to the giants.
Under the Hood:
The Honda Mobilio is expected to have the same 1.5 litre diesel and petrol engine that powers the Honda City. The diesel motor is capable of producing 100PS peak power at 3600rpm and 200Nm maximum torque at 1750rpm.
On the other hand, Ertiga has thesmallest diesel engine. It sports a 1.3 litre DDiS engine manufactured by Fiat.The 4 cylinder engine produces 90 PS peak power at 4000 rpm and an impressive200Nm torque at 1750 rpm. The engine though smaller is a better performer than Innova.
Innova Engine Mobilio Engine Ertiga Engine
Toyota’s Innova has the largest engine – the powerful 2.5 litre common rail which produces102Ps power at 3600 rpm and 200Nm torque at between 1200-3600 rpm.
Comparing the fuel efficiency, Mobilio comes out tops with a mind blowing 24.2 kmpl, Ertiga sports 20.77 kmpl whereas the Innova has a very disappointing 12 kmpl.
Honda Mobilio Vs Toyota Innova: Petrol Engine Specification
|
Specification
|
Honda Mobilio
|
Toyota Innova
|
|
Petrol Engine
|
1.5 litre
|
2.0 litre
|
|
Power (PS)
|
119
|
132
|
|
Torque (Nm)
|
145
|
181
|
|
Gearbox
|
5 – Speed MT
|
5 – Speed MT
|
|
Mileage (kmpl)
|
17.3 kmpl (expected)
|
11.4 kmpl
|
|
Dimension (LxWxH) in mm
|
4386 x 1683 x 1603
|
4585 x 1765 x 1760
|
|
Wheelbase in mm
|
2652
|
2750
|
|
Price in Lakhs
|
6.5 lakhs – 7.70 lakhs. (expected)
|
10.10 lakhs – 13.56 lakhs
|
Honda Mobilio Vs Toyota Innova: Diesel Engine Specification
|
Specification
|
Honda Mobilio
|
Toyota Innova
|
|
Diesel Engine
|
1.5 litre
|
2.5 litre
|
|
Power (PS)
|
100
|
102
|
|
Torque (Nm)
|
200
|
200
|
|
Gearbox
|
5 – Speed MT
|
5 – Speed MT
|
|
Mileage (kmpl)
|
24.2 kmpl (expected)
|
13.0 kmpl
|
|
Dimension (LxWxH) in mm
|
4386 x 1683 x 1603
|
4585 x 1765 x 1760
|
|
Wheelbase in mm
|
2652
|
2750
|
|
Price in Lakhs
|
7.70 lakhs – 9 lakhs (expected)
|
9.97 lakhs – 14.92 lakhs
|
Inside the Cabin
The Maruti Ertiga falls really short of its competitors in this space. The cabin doesn’t offer much space and the third row is very cramped. The ground clearance is decent at 185mm.
Mobilio on the other hand is continuing the tradition of offering lots of space like its older models like Jazz. The company has flexible seats like plenty of cubbyholes to store knick-knacks. Inspite of the height being 80mm less than that of the Ertiga, the Mobilio offers ample seating space and sufficient headroom. The third row also has sufficient space to make long drives comfortable.
Mobilio's Interiors Innova's Interiors
Another plus point is the boot space, which is also quite generous compared to the Ertiga. The ground clearance is kept at 189mm, which is a benefit for Indian road conditions.
Proportion wise, Toyota’s Innova is a game-changer. It has the largest dimensions though its ground clearance is the least at 176mm. Due to the large proportions it obviously offers excellent leg space but the overall size of the car makes it difficult to maneuver in the city traffic.
Honda Mobilio vs Maruti Ertiga Technical Comparison
|
|
Honda Mobilio
|
Maruti Ertiga
|
|
Height
|
1603 mm
|
1685 mm
|
|
Length
|
4386 mm
|
4265 mm
|
|
Width
|
1683 mm
|
1695 mm
|
|
Wheelbase
|
2650 mm
|
2740 mm
|
|
Ground Clearance
|
170 mm
|
185 mm
|
|
Petrol Engine
|
1.5 Lit 117 BHP, 146 NM
|
1.4 Lit, 95 BHP, 132 NM
|
|
Diesel Engine
|
1.5 Lit 100 BHP, 200 NM Torque
|
1.3 Lit, 90 BHP, 204 NM
|
|
Mileage (Petrol)
|
16 - 16.5 Kmpl
|
16 Kmpl Petrol
|
|
Mileage (Diesel)
|
23 - 24 Kmpl
|
20.78 Kmpl
|
Out of your pocket
Toyota is at the highest end of the spectrum with the price range being 12.93 lacs to 15.66 lacs. Despite of the expensive price tag it remains the favorite of the masses till date.
After the debacle with the Jazz, Honda has now got the knack of pricing its models and the Mobilio has been priced between the Ertiga and the Innova. This smart pricing will help it lure customers from both ends of the spectrum. The car is expected to be priced from Rs. 6.8 lac onwards.
Honda Mobilio vs Maruti Ertiga Price Comparison
|
|
Petrol
|
Diesel
|
|
Maruti Ertiga
|
INR 6.43 – 7.99 Lakhs
|
INR 7.94 – 9.28 Lakhs
|
|
Honda Mobilio
|
INR 6.24 - 7.9 Lakhs (expected)
|
INR 7.2 - 9 Lakhs (expected)
|
The Ertiga is at the bottom of the pyramid with the price range being Rs. 5.95 -8.32 lacs. Maruti’s vast after sale and service network is a big selling point for the Ertiga. Also, the small price tag is a good attraction for people looking at utility and not much worried about the brand image, looks and the premium feel.
Final Verdict
The Mobilio may have the smallest dimensions but it is a powerful offering from Honda’s stable. Expect it to shake up the market with the strikingly good looks, comfortable seating, best in class mileage and competitive price tag. The competitors should beware of the newcomer and start strategizing their comebacks.